Hi, How Can We Help You?

Child Abuse vs. Lawful Discipline in Arizona — ARS § 13-3623 Explained

Accused in Prescott or anywhere in Yavapai County? Child-abuse allegations can trigger both a criminal case and a DCS investigation. Get counsel before you speak with police, DCS, or school officials.

Free consultation — Ted Law (Prescott)
928-776-1782140 N Montezuma St, Prescott, AZ 86301


What Arizona Law Calls “Child Abuse” (ARS § 13-3623)

Under Arizona law, “child abuse” includes any of the following involving a minor:

  • Causing physical injury,

  • Allowing a child’s health to be injured while in your care/custody, or

  • Placing a child in a situation that endangers health or safety,

  • As well as unlawful imprisonment and sexual abuse/assault.

The charge level depends on both risk/ injury and your mental state:

  • Criminal negligenceClass 4 felony if circumstances were likely to cause death/serious injury (Class 6 if not likely).

  • RecklessnessClass 3 felony (Class 5 if not likely).

  • Intentional/Knowing (child under 15) → Class 2 felony (Class 4 if not likely).

Arizona also treats exposing a child to toxic/volatile chemicals (e.g., drug-lab environments) as child abuse.


Lawful Discipline vs. Abuse: Where Prescott Courts Draw the Line

Parents may use reasonable corporal discipline. It crosses into criminal conduct when:

  • There is actual injury (e.g., patterned bruises, fractures),

  • The method creates a substantial risk of serious harm, or

  • The force is unreasonable for the child’s age/size and the situation (object used, duration, location of marks).

Situations that often lead to charges or DCS findings in Yavapai County:

  • Striking with objects (belts/cords), shaking, grabbing that leaves bruises,

  • Locking a child in a room/garage (unlawful imprisonment),

  • Withholding medical care or leaving a child in a vehicle,

  • Proximity to drug manufacture or volatile chemicals.


What the Prosecutor Must Prove

To convict, the State must show beyond a reasonable doubt:

  1. Conduct: You caused/allowed injury or significant risk;

  2. Causation: Your act/omission led to the injury/risk;

  3. Mental state: Negligent, reckless, knowing, or intentional (as charged);

  4. Victim/Jurisdiction: The person harmed was a child in Arizona.

Evidence can include medical records, photos, officer body-cam, DCS reports, school/medical-provider statements, and any statements you made.


Prescott-Specific Realities (Yavapai County)

  • Parallel DCS cases: DCS can impose safety plans or file dependency actions even if criminal charges are reduced or dismissed.

  • Mandatory reporters: YRMC providers, teachers, and counselors must report; many cases start here.

  • Release conditions: No-contact orders and temporary custody limits are common—violations create new charges.


Defenses We Often Use

Every case is fact-specific, but effective defenses may include:

  • Reasonable parental discipline (minor, transient marks; proportionate force),

  • No criminal negligence / accident (and prompt medical care sought),

  • Alternative cause (sports injuries, medical conditions, accidental mechanisms),

  • Insufficient or unreliable proof (inconsistent accounts; flawed forensic conclusions),

  • Constitutional violations (unlawful search, Miranda/interrogation issues),

  • DCS procedure challenges (improper child interviews; incomplete investigation).


If You’re Accused in Prescott: Do & Don’t

Do

  • Say: “I’m invoking my right to remain silent and my right to an attorney.”

  • Preserve evidence (date-stamped photos, texts, medical records); list witnesses.

  • Follow all court/DCS orders to the letter.

Don’t

  • Don’t speak to police or DCS without counsel.

  • Don’t contact the reporting party to “clear it up.”

  • Don’t post about the case online.


Possible Penalties (Snapshot)

Depending on the felony class and history, child-abuse convictions can bring prison, probation limits, fines/restitution, and long-term effects on gun rights, employment/licensing, immigration, and custody. A targeted strategy can sometimes reduce charges (e.g., to disorderly conduct or endangerment) or achieve dismissal where proof falls short.


Talk to a Prescott Child-Abuse Defense Lawyer Now

Early intervention can protect your rights and shape outcomes in both criminal court and DCS.

Ted Law | DUI & Criminal Defense — Prescott
140 N Montezuma St, Prescott, AZ 86301
Call 928-776-1782Free, confidential consult (phone/video/in-person)

This page is general information, not legal advice. For guidance on your specific situation, contact our Prescott office.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This field is required.

You may use these <abbr title="HyperText Markup Language">html</abbr> tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

*This field is required.